Chapel Sweets

- 225 Weldon's Way, New Shoreham, RI 02807

For more than two decades, Chapel Sweets was a beloved and iconic institution on Block Island, a true Rhode Island gem that created sweet memories for countless visitors and locals. This small business was more than just a chocolate shop or a candy store; it was a slice of coastal charm and a destination for those who cherished old-fashioned quality and a touch of nostalgia. Though the owners have since retired, their legacy of creating exceptional confections, particularly their legendary fudge, remains a fond memory for all who were lucky enough to visit. The shop embodied the spirit of Block Island, offering a warm welcome and delicious treats that were a highlight of any trip.

At its heart, Chapel Sweets was a haven for lovers of classic candy and fudge. The store's reputation was built on its soft and creamy fudge, which was available in a wide variety of flavors, including fan favorites like penuche with walnuts, cookies and cream, chocolate peanut butter, and a rich chocolate vanilla swirl. Beyond fudge, the shop offered a "nostalgic candy & nut" selection, which included classic items that brought back fond childhood memories. One customer noted the "very smooth" white chocolate truffle, which was a favorite for aficionados of white chocolate. Another highly-praised creation was the famous "Sandy Feet Turtle," a signature item that was a must-try for many visitors. The dedication to quality was a hallmark of the business, ensuring that every piece of candy was not just a treat, but a delightful experience.

The warmth of the shop's atmosphere was inseparable from the kindness of its owners and staff. Customers consistently praised the "very kind staff" and the "super nice older gentleman" who ran the shop, noting his "service with a smile." This personal, friendly service was what turned first-time visitors into loyal, repeat customers who would "come back year after year" to see the owner and enjoy the wonderful products. It was this perfect combination of excellent confections and genuine hospitality that made Chapel Sweets a quintessential Block Island experience.

Chapel Sweets was located at 225 Weldon's Way, New Shoreham, RI 02807, USA. This location was perfectly situated for visitors to Block Island, as it was only one block up from the Interstate Navigation ferry landing in Old Harbor. Its prime position made it a convenient and eagerly anticipated stop for travelers arriving on the island, serving as a welcoming introduction to the local charm. For those already on the island, its central location made it an easy and delightful detour during a day of exploring.

The shop was an integral part of the vibrant Weldon's Way area, which is known for its charming collection of local businesses. This central location allowed for a convenient and stress-free visit. Being in such a popular and accessible part of New Shoreham meant that visitors could easily stop by the shop to pick up a dessert or a gift before continuing on their journey. The store's prominence and easy access from the ferry landing made it a memorable part of the Block Island experience for anyone who stepped foot on the island. While the physical storefront may have closed, its address on Weldon’s Way remains a landmark in the minds of those who visited.

The fact that it was so close to the main ferry terminal meant that it was an essential part of a trip for many people, a sweet bookmark at the beginning or end of their visit to Block Island. This prime location ensured that it was not just a business, but a genuine part of the community and the island's unique identity.

During its years of operation, Chapel Sweets offered a range of services that were tailored to their customers' needs, both on and off the island.

• In-store shopping: Customers were able to browse a large selection of chocolates, fudge, and candies in the charming store environment.

• Onsite services: The staff, known for their kindness and helpfulness, provided personal assistance and recommendations to shoppers.

• Takeout: All products were available for takeout, allowing visitors to grab their favorite treats to enjoy later or on their journey home.

• Shipping Service: For those who wanted to enjoy their favorite Chapel Sweets products from afar, the business happily shipped their products. They preferred to handle these orders over the phone to ensure accuracy and personal service.

Chapel Sweets was a standout business for a number of reasons, all of which contributed to its lasting legacy.

• Legendary Fudge: The "soft and creamy" fudge was the star of the show. Customers loved the variety of flavors, from classic chocolate and peanut butter to unique penuche with walnuts, making it a must-try for any fudge enthusiast.

• Exceptional Service: The owners were known for their genuine kindness and excellent customer service, which made every visit a warm and welcoming experience. Their personal attention to detail and friendly demeanor created a loyal customer base.

• Nostalgic Charm: The store had a "nostalgic" atmosphere, evoking a sense of timelessness and simplicity that made it a cherished destination. It wasn’t just a shop; it was a journey back in time.

• Unique Products: In addition to the famous fudge, the shop offered unique creations like the "Sandy Feet Turtle," as well as a variety of nut clusters, barks, and classic candies, providing a diverse selection for every taste.

• Media Recognition: The store's fudge was so famous that it was even featured on HGTV's show "Island Life," cementing its reputation as a must-visit spot on Block Island.

• Part of the Block Island Experience: For many, a trip to the island was incomplete without a stop at Chapel Sweets. It was an iconic part of the local culture and a place where traditions were made year after year.

The legacy of this beloved small business can be remembered through its contact information:

Address: 225 Weldon's Way, New Shoreham, RI 02807, USA

Phone: (401) 466-2672

Chapel Sweets was truly a Block Island treasure, and what made it so worth choosing was its unwavering commitment to quality and heart. The shop's delicious, "soft and creamy" fudge was its most famous offering, and it was a taste that lived up to its reputation. Beyond the confections, the personal and warm service provided by the owners made every customer feel like a friend, not just a patron. This combination of superior products and genuine hospitality created an experience that was both sweet and memorable.

For those in Rhode Island who had the chance to visit, Chapel Sweets was more than a place to buy candy; it was a tradition, a source of nostalgic joy, and a testament to the power of a small business dedicated to its craft. While the physical shop may be closed, its legacy lives on in the memories of the many people who savored a piece of its delicious fudge, took home a bag of its nostalgic candies, and shared a kind word with its wonderful owners. Chapel Sweets will be forever remembered as a cherished part of the Block Island community and a benchmark for what a truly great candy store can be.

Chapel Sweets

225 Weldon's Way, New Shoreham, RI 02807, USA