The Sweet Shop NYC Introduce
Welcome to The Sweet Shop NYC, a delightful and beloved small business nestled in the vibrant neighborhood of the Upper East Side. For anyone in New York City with a craving for a little sweetness and a touch of nostalgia, this is the perfect destination. The Sweet Shop NYC is more than just a place to buy candy; it's a sensory experience designed to transport you back in time. The moment you walk in, you’re greeted with a joyful atmosphere that feels like a throwback to a classic, old-fashioned candy store. We are a family-run business, and we've put our heart and soul into creating a place that sparks a childhood memory in everyone who visits, whether you're a kid or just a kid at heart. Our commitment to curated, high-quality sweets and a warm, personal service sets us apart.
The Sweet Shop NYC is a true sweet lover’s paradise, offering an impressive variety of treats that go beyond the typical candy store. In addition to our vast candy selection, we also operate as a cookie shop, a dessert shop, and an ice cream shop. Our ice cream is a particular highlight, sourced from some of New York's top makers. We pride ourselves on offering a delicious range of options, from classic flavors like "Party Animal" to custom creations. We also serve fresh-baked cookies, which are perfect on their own or as a part of a delectable ice cream sandwich. Our dedication to a diverse and high-quality menu of desserts ensures that every visit is a memorable one. The store's unique retro vibe and "Willy Wonka-esque" decor add to the charm, making it a wonderful place to explore. As a small business, we love to share our passion for sweets and create an environment where customers feel welcome and can find a treat that truly brings them joy.
The Sweet Shop NYC is located at 404 E 73rd St, New York, NY 10021, USA, in a charming part of the Upper East Side. This neighborhood spot is a true community gem, easily accessible for residents and a worthwhile destination for anyone in the city. While specific public transit routes are numerous in this part of Manhattan, the location is conveniently situated for a quick visit. Whether you're walking from a nearby apartment or taking a short cab ride, getting here is a breeze. The presence of a lovely tree and some outdoor seating provides a pleasant place to rest and enjoy your treats, as noted by a customer who found it a nice spot for shade and a break.
The accessibility and convenience of our services are a key part of our appeal. The Sweet Shop NYC is designed for a quick and easy visit, which is a significant advantage in a fast-paced city. We accept all major credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, making transactions swift and seamless. For those who prefer to shop from home, we offer a variety of convenient service options, including delivery and curbside pickup. This ensures that you can enjoy our delicious sweets no matter where you are or what your schedule looks like. Our commitment to efficiency and customer convenience makes every visit, whether in person or online, a positive experience. We are proud to be a neighborhood fixture that prioritizes customer satisfaction and a hassle-free process.
Services Offered:
- Curbside pickup: Place your order ahead of time and pick it up easily from the curb without having to leave your car, a great option for those on the go.
- Delivery: We offer delivery services, allowing you to enjoy our delicious candy, cookies, and ice cream from the comfort of your own home.
- In-store pickup: Order online or by phone and have your order ready for a quick and easy pickup inside the store.
- In-store shopping: Experience our wide selection of sweets in person, where you can take your time to browse and get recommendations from our friendly staff.
- Onsite services: We provide a full-service experience, with our team ready to assist you in finding the perfect treat, from a scoop of ice cream to a bag of nostalgic candy.
Features and Highlights:
- Amazing Selection of Nostalgic Candy: Our store is a treasure trove of nostalgic and hard-to-find candies that evoke wonderful childhood memories, as a British customer pointed out. This unique selection sets us apart.
- Friendly and Helpful Staff: Our team, particularly a staff member named Matthew, is praised for being super helpful, knowledgeable, and genuinely friendly. The staff's approach is to provide a no-pressure, helpful experience.
- Delicious Ice Cream and Desserts: We are a beloved ice cream spot, offering delicious flavors and unique dessert creations, like our ice cream sandwiches, that are highly praised by customers.
- Small Business with a Heart: As a small, family-owned business, we are committed to providing a personal touch and a warm, welcoming atmosphere that makes every customer feel like a part of the neighborhood.
- Convenient Payment Options: We accept credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, making your purchase quick and easy, which is perfect for a quick visit.
Contact Information:
Address: 404 E 73rd St, New York, NY 10021, USA
Phone: (212) 960-8685
What is Worth Choosing:
The Sweet Shop NYC is worth choosing for anyone in New York City looking for a truly special sweet experience. What makes us stand out is our unique blend of a nostalgic atmosphere and a diverse, high-quality product offering. We are not just a candy store; we are a destination for amazing ice cream, fresh cookies, and a wide array of delicious desserts. The fact that we are a small, family-owned business with a passion for what we do shines through in every interaction, making your visit feel personal and meaningful. A customer's detailed review perfectly captures this, highlighting a staff member's genuine helpfulness, kindness, and the delightful surprise of finding nostalgic candies. This kind of experience, where staff go out of their way to ensure a customer's happiness, is what we pride ourselves on.
While a quick visit is certainly an option, the atmosphere and friendly service will make you want to linger. The British customer's experience, where they felt welcomed even near closing time and regretted not buying more, is a testament to the positive environment we've cultivated. The availability of curbside pickup and delivery services also makes us a convenient choice, ensuring you can get your sweet fix whenever and wherever you are. By choosing The Sweet Shop NYC, you are supporting a local small business that is dedicated to bringing joy and deliciousness to its community. It's a place where every item tells a story and every visit creates a new, wonderful memory, making it a truly rewarding choice for any sweet craving.
The Sweet Shop NYC Details
From the business
- Small business
Service options
- Curbside pickup
- Delivery
- In-store pickup
- In-store shopping
- Onsite services
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
The Sweet Shop NYC Photos










The Sweet Shop NYC Location
The Sweet Shop NYC
404 E 73rd St, New York, NY 10021, USA
The Sweet Shop NYC Reviews
carameldoormarshmallowflavorsmenuscoopsice cream shopchocolate chip cookiesaltedcone
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1Lovely Ice Cream Spot!Stopped by and had the party animal with the sugar waffle cone! It was Delicious. The service was very quick and the server was friendly! Very friendly neighborhood spot!
June 01 · Sharna MandrieHappened Amon this amazing store by chance. I went near closing. Matthew was super helpful. I sat outside and couldn’t decide. He allowed me to come in and take a load of photos. As a Brit I was surprised to find a load of sweets I normally like. Especially the gummy cola bottles. I’m almost 50 years old and the memories were wonderful. Matthew showed me some alternatives. I felt a bit rushed as I realized the time but he didn’t mention anything. No hard sell which was also great. I regret not buying more stuff as I got to a friends birthday party and sweets got devoured! (50/50 Brits / NYers). Popping candy was a hit. I saved some lCandy buttons for cupcakes I’m making. I was advised they won’t melt in buttercream (Yay). I’m definitely going back for more sweets and will try an ice cream. I’m pretty sure Matthew gave me a complimentary lollipop! The one on the pic. The rest is what survived the party. Brown bag was the cola bottle bag. A couple of seats outside under a tree. Which was nice for a rest and shade. Definitely go and check this place out. I’m so glad I came across it as I’ll be a regular.🫶🏾 Matthew.
July 11 · Ebony EvansThe desserts here are good, but the service is incredibly unreliable. I've ordered from this place multiple times, and it's a recurring pattern: they accept the order, make you wait a half hour or more, then suddenly cancel with no explanation. It’s incredibly frustrating—especially when you’re counting on them for a special occasion. Most recently, they completely ruined my birthday dessert. I waited over 90 minutes, only to have the order canceled last-minute. No communication, no update, nothing.
July 17 · Tara SchwartzThere are plenty of chain ice cream and candy shops all over the city, but there is only one Sweet Shop in the city. Everything they got is on another level, they love what they do and want to make sure you left with a tasty treat that prompts you to come back. The owner would let us try some new candy that he wanted us to enjoy.
April 05 · Shawn ShirianOrdered from uber eats and everything was amazing! Boyfriend got the Cola float, we split a chocolate chip cookie, and I got the edible cookie dough.Everything was packaged perfectly & so delicious! Can’t wait to come by in person (and the cookie was to DIE for!)
June 23 · leah
More Candy Store Near Me

111 14th St, Hoboken, NJ 07030, USA

484 Broome St, New York, NY 10013, USA

100 Centre St, New York, NY 10013, USA

105 4th St, Hoboken, NJ 07030, USA

185 Greenwich St, New York, NY 10007, USA

120 Broadway, New York, NY 10271, USA

170 53rd St #216, Brooklyn, NY 11232, USA

296B Stuyvesant Ave, Lyndhurst, NJ 07071, USA

1232 Surf Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224, USA

651 Kapkowski Rd Suite #1274, Elizabeth, NJ 07201, USA

8 Barrett Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302, USA

1400 Willowbrook Mall, Wayne, NJ 07470, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Trending Candy Chronicles Posts





