The Candied Anchor

- 721 Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954

In the picturesque coastal town of Montauk, New York, The Candied Anchor stands out as a true local treasure. This charming, women-owned small business is more than just a candy store; it’s a modern sweet shop with a whimsical, old-fashioned sensibility. As a must-stop spot for both locals and visitors, it has a reputation for being a place that captures the fun and joy of a classic American sweet shop while offering a unique and diverse selection that caters to every taste.

The store has been praised by customers as a place with "A+" quality and "lots of great stuff." It successfully blends the nostalgic charm of a 1950s candy store with a modern, bohemian twist. This unique aesthetic, combined with a friendly and welcoming atmosphere, makes it a destination that both kids and adults "love." The Candied Anchor is a place where you can rediscover your favorite childhood candies and at the same time, explore new and unusual sweets from all over the world. This delightful mix ensures that every visit is a fun and exciting adventure.

Beyond its vast selection of candies, The Candied Anchor also functions as a gift shop, offering a curated collection of "cute gifts" and quirky retro items. This makes it an ideal spot for finding the perfect souvenir, a thoughtful present for a friend, or even for stocking up on unique party supplies. The business prides itself on its inclusivity, identifying as an LGBTQ+ friendly establishment, which further adds to its welcoming and open-minded spirit.

The Candied Anchor is a testament to the fact that small businesses can create a big impact. Its commitment to providing a high-quality product, combined with exceptional service and a unique charm, has made it a beloved fixture in the Montauk community. Whether you're in the mood for a classic treat or a new flavor adventure, this spot is guaranteed to leave you with a sweet taste and a happy memory.

The Candied Anchor is perfectly situated in the heart of Montauk at 721 Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954, USA. Its location on Montauk Highway makes it easily accessible for anyone visiting or passing through the town, whether they're coming from the Hamptons or the easternmost point of Long Island. The central location makes it a convenient and essential stop for anyone exploring the area.

The store is committed to providing a welcoming experience for all customers, with a strong focus on accessibility. The Candied Anchor features a wheelchair-accessible entrance, ensuring that everyone can easily come in and browse the delightful selection. It also provides a wheelchair-accessible parking lot, making it a stress-free stop for those with mobility needs.

The central location also means it is in easy walking distance from other shops, restaurants, and attractions in Montauk. This makes it a great spot to pop in for a quick visit or a planned stop while exploring the town. The convenience of its location and its dedication to accessibility make it a top choice for a sweet outing.

• In-Store Shopping: Customers can come in and browse the wide selection of candies, gifts, and baked confections. The self-serve candy bar is a popular feature, allowing you to create your own personalized mix of favorites.

• Delivery: For those who can't make it to the store, The Candied Anchor offers a delivery service. This is a convenient option for sending a sweet treat to a loved one or for getting your favorites brought right to your door in Montauk.

• Wide Variety of Candies: The store offers a huge selection of sweets, including nostalgic classics like Mary Janes and Charleston Chews, as well as unique international sweets. They also cater to various dietary needs with options that are sugar-free, gluten-free, and nut-free.

• Gifts and Party Supplies: The Candied Anchor is more than just a candy shop. They offer a great range of "cute gifts," quirky retro items, and a full line of party supplies for any occasion, including birthdays and baby showers. They even offer custom-made decor and bespoke party planning services.

• Custom Gift Baskets: The shop is known for its ability to create custom gift baskets, which are perfect for special occasions. The staff is happy to work with you to create a personalized, one-of-a-kind gift.

• Unique and Diverse Selection: The store's selection is a major highlight. It’s a great mix of "classic candies" and "new local delicacies," such as goat's milk caramels. This variety, including unique items like "spicy gummies," ensures there is something to appeal to every palate.

• Friendly and Accommodating Staff: The staff at The Candied Anchor are consistently praised for being "super sweet and funny," as well as "amiable and accommodating." Their excellent service makes the shopping experience even more enjoyable.

• Women-Owned Small Business: As a proud women-owned small business, The Candied Anchor embodies the entrepreneurial spirit and a dedication to its craft. This local identity makes it a special place to support and visit.

• Charming and Unique Atmosphere: The store’s aesthetic is described as the "cutest," with a vibe that is a blend of classic Americana and organic Bohemia. This creates a fun and inviting environment that is a joy to be in.

• LGBTQ+ Friendly: The business proudly identifies as an LGBTQ+ friendly space, which contributes to a welcoming and inclusive environment for everyone in the community.

Address: 721 Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954, USA

Phone: (631) 668-8038

When you're looking for a sweet treat in Montauk, New York, The Candied Anchor is a choice that is absolutely worth making. What truly sets this store apart is its exceptional balance of classic charm and modern sensibility. It's not just a place to buy candy; it's a nostalgic and delightful experience that captures the essence of a traditional sweet shop while offering a unique and diverse selection of products you won't find anywhere else. The ability to find everything from classic gummy bears to locally-made goat's milk caramels makes it a destination for both the young and the young at heart.

Beyond the products, the store’s atmosphere and the people who run it are a major reason to visit. The Candied Anchor is praised for being "the cutest candy store" with a warm and welcoming feel. The staff’s friendliness and genuine passion for what they do create a positive and memorable shopping experience that encourages you to return. The fact that it is a women-owned, LGBTQ+ friendly small business also makes it a place you can feel good about supporting.

Ultimately, The Candied Anchor is a must-stop spot in Montauk because it offers so much more than just candy. It's a place to find unique gifts, plan a party, and, most importantly, create a lasting memory. It perfectly embodies the sweet, unique, and welcoming spirit of Montauk.

The Candied Anchor

721 Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954, USA