Cape Cod Salt Water Taffy Introduce
For generations of Massachusetts residents and visitors to Cape Cod, a trip to the beach is incomplete without a taste of classic salt water taffy. In South Yarmouth, one business has been a staple for this quintessential treat: Cape Cod Salt Water Taffy. Located right on Route 28, this charming candy store is a beloved local small business that has been serving up sweet, chewy delights since 1952. It is a place where tradition and flavor come together, offering a unique experience for anyone looking for a taste of authentic Cape Cod nostalgia. The shop is more than just a place to buy candy; it’s a living part of the region's history, where the original Mermaid Brand Taffy is crafted. This article will provide an in-depth look at what makes Cape Cod Salt Water Taffy a special and worthy stop on your next journey to the Cape, highlighting its extensive flavor selection, convenient location, and the authentic experience it offers.
The essence of Cape Cod Salt Water Taffy is in its commitment to a timeless tradition. While some taffy is mass-produced, this shop prides itself on being one of the last authentic taffy kitchens in the East. Here, you can watch candymakers work their 50-pound loaves of taffy onto pulling machines, a fascinating process that creates the velvety-smooth texture that the candy is known for. This hands-on approach to candy making ensures that every piece has a superior quality and a fresh flavor that truly stands out. A customer review highlights this commitment to quality, describing the shop as a "great find" for getting your "must have Taffy's when you come to the Cape." The shop's charm is its authenticity, offering a simple yet deeply satisfying experience. While some recent reviews have noted a change in product quality, it's important to recognize that the shop has a long-standing history and reputation for being a go-to spot for many. Its continued operation is a testament to its popularity and its role as a local landmark.
Cape Cod Salt Water Taffy is conveniently situated at 984 MA-28 in South Yarmouth, MA 02664, USA. Its location directly on Route 28 makes it a highly visible and easy-to-access roadside attraction. For those traveling by car, there is plenty of parking available, which is a significant highlight mentioned by a customer. This accessibility makes it an ideal spot for a quick visit, whether you're driving to or from the beach or simply taking a scenic drive through the area. The building itself, often described as a charming roadside stand or a "fruit stand" for taffy, has an inviting, no-frills appeal. Its proximity to other Cape Cod attractions and its easy parking make it a hassle-free stop for a sweet treat.
As an authentic candy store, Cape Cod Salt Water Taffy focuses on providing a classic, in-person shopping experience. Their services are designed to be straightforward and customer-friendly.
- Onsite services: The main service offered is the in-store experience, which includes the opportunity to "fill your own box from the rainbow display." This self-serve model allows customers to choose from a vast array of flavors, creating a personalized assortment. The process of picking and mixing is a large part of the fun and is a key feature of the shop.
- Payment options: To make transactions simple, the store accepts both debit cards and NFC mobile payments, catering to modern payment preferences.
Cape Cod Salt Water Taffy is distinguished by several key features and highlights that make it a unique destination.
- Vast selection of flavors: The shop is known for its immense variety, with a review noting "so many to choose from!" and a history of offering over 31 different flavors. This wide selection, which includes unique options like "fluffanutter," ensures there is a flavor for every palate.
- Authentic taffy-making process: As one of the last authentic taffy kitchens in the region, the store provides an opportunity to see the taffy-pulling machines in action, a fascinating glimpse into the old-fashioned candy-making process.
- The original Mermaid Brand Taffy: The store is the home of the original Mermaid Brand Taffy, a name that has become synonymous with quality on the Cape. This brand recognition adds a layer of authenticity and trust for long-time customers.
- Affordable prices: A customer review highlights that the "prices are great!!", making it an accessible treat for all.
- Free parking: The availability of "plenty of parking" is a practical highlight that makes a visit to the shop stress-free and convenient.
To get in touch with Cape Cod Salt Water Taffy, you can reach them by phone at (508) 394-7557 or their mobile number, +1 508-394-7557. Their address is 984 MA-28, South Yarmouth, MA 02664, USA.
What makes Cape Cod Salt Water Taffy truly worth choosing for a Massachusetts resident or visitor? It is the unparalleled combination of tradition, variety, and the authentic Cape Cod experience. While other shops sell taffy, this is one of the few places where you can witness the traditional taffy-making process and take home a product that is part of the region's culinary history. The ability to create your own custom bag from over 30 flavors allows for a truly personalized and delightful experience, with unique flavors like fluffanutter standing out. While one customer's recent review mentioned a negative experience with the texture, it is important to consider the many positive reviews that celebrate the shop's unique and flavorful offerings. The overall consensus from many customers is that it is a "great find" and a "must-have" part of their trip. The shop's status as a small business that has been operating since 1952 speaks volumes about its enduring appeal and its role as a local landmark. By choosing Cape Cod Salt Water Taffy, you are not just buying candy; you are participating in a cherished Cape Cod tradition, supporting a local institution, and getting a delicious, nostalgic treat that perfectly captures the spirit of the seaside.
Cape Cod Salt Water Taffy Details
From the business
- Small business
Service options
- Onsite services
Payments
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Cape Cod Salt Water Taffy Photos










Cape Cod Salt Water Taffy Location
Cape Cod Salt Water Taffy
984 MA-28, South Yarmouth, MA 02664, USA
Cape Cod Salt Water Taffy Reviews
flavorschoicepricekidspeanut buttersaltwatersummerbagpick your ownsouvenir
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1This was a great find!! Aunique way to pick up some of your must have Taffy's when you come to the Cape.Friendly staff. So many to choose from! Diffent flavors like fluffanutter or classic orange! Plenty of Parking. Prices are great!!
May 26 · Kristina “Chicklassique” MateoI’m sorry but WHAT HAPPENED?!?! This place used to have the softest most flavorful taffy in all of Yarmouth. I just took my husband to show him the place I’ve been coming to since I was a little kid and he broke a crown off in the taffy after I had spit my first piece back out! What the hell. As a life long customer I’m absolutely going to stop recommending.
August 29 · Laurel HampelWe bought the Saltwater Taffy from here. Been a few years since we’ve been to the Cape. So pleased we stopped and bought our Taffy from here. Still taste the saltwater and the flavor of each candy. Thank you for consistency.
August 19 · Cynthia KochGreat product. Never had a bad experience here. Employees are always warm and welcoming. However, whoever the gal was running the stand on the night of 07/30/2025, I get it was late and you wanted to leave, but that is no excuse for attitude. Not just at me but at the lovely family in front of me too. Service with a smile you absolutely did not have.
July 31 · Nicole TerryI have been going here since I was a kid. It was a must stop when we were in the Cape and now it's a must stop for my own family. Prices are good and so are the flavors. This Taffy is so much better than the pre-packaged stuff you get at say Cuffys. Some might like that stuff but not me I like the real deal! They are always polite there and you can even sample a flavor before you pick them out! Keep it up guys! See you next year!
July 17 · Sbedford7252
More Candy Store Near Me

484 Broome St, New York, NY 10013, USA

100 Centre St, New York, NY 10013, USA

111 14th St, Hoboken, NJ 07030, USA

185 Greenwich St, New York, NY 10007, USA

120 Broadway, New York, NY 10271, USA

105 4th St, Hoboken, NJ 07030, USA

1232 Surf Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224, USA

170 53rd St #216, Brooklyn, NY 11232, USA

296B Stuyvesant Ave, Lyndhurst, NJ 07071, USA

8 Barrett Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302, USA

1400 Willowbrook Mall, Wayne, NJ 07470, USA

651 Kapkowski Rd Suite #1274, Elizabeth, NJ 07201, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Trending Candy Chronicles Posts





